With ever-changing market conditions, there is no such thing as a simple commercial real estate sales transaction. The complexity increases even more when the transaction involves a court-appointed receiver (someone given the responsibility of a property).
There are many reasons why a commercial property, secured by a loan, would be forced into foreclosure. Poor economic conditions and bad management are probably the two largest drivers. Rather than resorting to costly foreclosure proceedings, some commercial real estate lenders consider commercial real estate receivership as a preferable alternative.
Continue reading to learn more about receiverships in commercial real estate and their potential benefits.
How Does a Commercial Real Estate Receivership Work?
A commercial real estate receivership is an affordable alternative to a foreclosure proceeding (a lender takes ownership of the project) or a bankruptcy proceeding (a trustee takes control of the project).
When foreclosures occur, the borrower typically stays in control of the property and its income. If struggling financially, the borrower may use the property’s income to pay off other debts instead of covering the property’s expenses. This type of neglect puts the property’s value in jeopardy, meaning that the lender could lose even more money on the sale of the property. When bankruptcy proceedings take place, the lender may need to get in line behind other creditors (for example, in the cases of a second mortgage or a general business bankruptcy).
To mitigate this risk, commercial real estate lenders turn to a receivership. A receivership transfers control of a property’s management from the borrower to a neutral third party, known as the receiver.
What Is a Receiver in Commercial Real Estate?
Receivers in commercial real estate are court-appointed individuals given responsibility of a property that serves as the collateral for a loan in default. The receiver displaces the property owner as the active property manager and is responsible for tasks like collecting rent, maintaining and repairing the property, and ensuring contractors and service providers are paid.
A general receiver is granted control over all of an entity’s assets (often to liquidate a business), while a limited receiver controls only one or more specific assets. In both cases, the receiver acts in the best interests of both the lender and borrower.
While receivers take orders directly from the court, they must:
- Act in the best interests of both the borrower and the lender.
- Not act for their own benefit.
- Not go against the interests of the borrower and the lender.
Benefits of CRE Receivership
Commercial real estate foreclosure proceedings take a significant amount of time and are relatively expensive to complete. Here are a few of the benefits of turning to a receivership instead:
- Save time and money. A receivership sale can be completed quickly and eliminates the fees associated with foreclosures.
- More experience. Compared to bankruptcy trustees, commercial real estate receivers tend to have the expertise required to analyze, appraise, and effectively market the property’s value.
- Prevent waste. The receiver’s experience also helps to prioritize capital expenditures and maintain the physical asset and its value.
- Lenders and borrowers benefit. Because the receiver acts in the best interest of both parties, the borrower can negotiate a better outcome to his or her default and the lender can earn greater proceeds from the property’s sale.
Case Study: Worldwide Beauty Product Manufacturer Secures Property Through Receivership
Allegro Real Estate Brokers & Advisors represented a locally-based company that manufactures and sells professional beauty products worldwide in its search to acquire a permanent industrial home. Among other options, Allegro identified a property being sold through a receiver. The prior owner had built the building in 2006, financed primarily with bonds issued by the state of Ohio. After almost two hundred years in business, the owner declared bankruptcy and defaulted on the bonds.
The property was initially listed for sale by a third-party broker for $4.5 million, which was the break-even number for the state of Ohio’s outstanding bonds and the other outstanding creditors. After the broker unsuccessfully solicited sufficient offers for a period of six months, Allegro assisted its client to submit a signed purchase agreement with no financing contingency through its attorney. After several months of negotiations, the receiver sought approval of the Court to countersign the purchase agreement. At that time, the state of Ohio did not give its consent to the transaction.
Within two weeks of requesting approval, the court entered an order granting the receiver authority to execute the purchase agreement. Along with the client’s attorney, Allegro began its due diligence period, all the while understanding that closing on the property was still subject to a final, non-appealable order. The order would not occur until 30 days had passed and none of the stakeholders had filed either a motion to vacate the order or an appeal.
In a transaction like this, one of the main concerns is a creditor appealing the order after the buyer begins its due diligence, but prior to the end of the 30-day waiting period required by the receivership process. This may happen due to another buyer expressing interest in purchasing the property for more money. In this case, the state became aware of another buyer’s intention of paying more for the property and thus filed a Motion to Vacate Order. The state did not withdraw this motion and allowed the time for appeal to lapse until negotiations were completed with all of the parties and Allegro’s client minimally increased its purchase price. The property closed roughly two weeks later for a little over 50% of the initial asking price.
Receiverships can be advantageous to struggling commercial real estate owners and their lenders, but can be complicated to execute. It is critical to fully understand the procedure and all the possible pitfalls and be supported by a strong team of professional service providers before undertaking such a deal.
Want More Commercial Real Estate Resources?
Our blog features frequent content, straight from our commercial real estate experts. Subscribe to receive weekly content right in your inbox, on topics like advice and opinions on the state of the industry, market reports, and updates about the Allegro team.
Editor’s note: This post was originally published in 2016, and has been updated and republished.